So you just found out that you are going to be a parent or a grandparent. Congratulations! Now starts the fun of readying the nursery for the new arrival. It’s hard to choose from the dizzying array of products you find, as you weigh price, functionality, space considerations, and need. But what about health? Is that even something you need to factor in as you make your decisions?
What Makes a Nursery and Baby Product Non-Toxic?
Recently, a health-conscious friend of mine became a first-time, can’t-wait grandmother. As she searched online for items her son and daughter-in-law would need, it didn’t take her long to become exasperated at the vague product information and varied safety claims. Since I created the Environment module of the Anticancer Lifestyle Program, my friend figured I would know how to help her sort through this tangled thicket of products and claims. I got the frantic phone call: “What does this certification mean? Is it legit? Is there a way to be sure this car seat is non-toxic?”
These are the kinds of questions you may be wondering about as well, so let’s address them. To get started, you’ll often see baby products labeled as “non-toxic”, or conversely, you’ll run into items that detractors label as “toxic.” There are no formal, legal definitions of these terms when it comes to consumer products. Most products made for babies are neither completely pure nor completely noxious. When considering products to purchase, it’s important to remember as small and rapidly developing beings, babies may be more affected than adults by even low concentrations of toxic chemicals.
Who Regulates the Safety of Baby Products?
You might be shocked that the government is not completely protecting you and your baby from known health hazards. The fact is, most products we find on our store shelves are very poorly regulated. When legal limits for some hazardous chemicals do exist, the levels are often set quite a bit higher than what most scientists would consider truly safe. One reason for this is that a hazard is usually measured based on a one-time limited exposure, and not as a result of its cumulative effects over time.
Here’s a quick rough formula you can use when weighing the relative health hazard of any given product: Risk = degree of hazard X exposure time. Applying this formula will guide you away from products that are best avoided. As an example of how to use this formula, let’s take a deep dive into one common nursery item: the crib. While the US government does regulate the physical characteristics of cribs (ie, the distance between slats), there is very little regulation concerning toxicity in crib components.
Read Next | 5 Things to Do Before Bringing Your Baby Home from the Hospital
Cribs and Mattresses
Typically, cribs are made of pressed wood, and crib mattresses are usually made of polyurethane foam and covered with vinyl. Your baby will spend a lot of time sleeping in the crib, over a couple of years, which equals lots of exposure time. Pressed wood contains glues that can emit toxic compounds, known as “volatile organic chemicals” or VOCs. These chemicals evaporate easily at room temperature in a process known as “off-gassing.”
What about the mattress? According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA), exposure to some of the main ingredients of polyurethane foam – isocyanates – can cause a range of negative health effects when they off-gas, including asthma, lung damage and respiratory problems, along with skin and eye irritation. In addition, many crib mattresses contain flame retardants, which are highly toxic chemicals. As to the vinyl cover: vinyl is considered the worst of plastics in terms of off-gassing several toxic VOCs, including phthalates, which are known hormone-disrupting chemicals.
Referring back to our formula, a standard crib doesn’t fare well, as your baby will have a lot of exposure time to many different chemicals of concern.
So, what to do? Solid wood cribs with wool mattresses are not only hard to find, but they are expensive. Let’s face it, very few people can afford to buy everything brand new, all organic, or with the best certifications. That’s why I urge you to consider the relative risk as you gauge where it’s worth spending top dollar, if needed, to avoid toxic exposures.
Where Do Babies Absorb Toxins?
In general, these are the routes of baby’s exposure I recommend focusing on:
Nose. Other than sleep a lot, babies also breathe a lot! Air can contain little bits of stuff—such as microplastics, dirt, soot, and dust—that are so small they float. Many chemicals attach to dust. This is one reason why choosing natural, untreated products versus synthetics and plastics (that often shed tiny particles) is a better choice. VOCs from flame retardants, fragrances, cleaning products, paints, cooking, oven cleaning, dry cleaning, and plastics like vinyl are released from all sorts of products. No plug-in air fresheners in the nursery! Try to keep the air truly fresh.
I also put electromagnetic fields, or EMFs, in the air category. A baby’s principal exposure to these would most likely come from baby monitors. Monitors have become quite sophisticated, which unfortunately means greater exposure to EMFs. Because monitors are used mostly when a baby sleeps, the exposure time can add up. Low emission analog type monitors are the safest but don’t include video. Sometimes we can’t have it all.
Mouth: Babies put a lot of things in their mouths! If the baby uses a pacifier or a teether, that means a lot of contact time. These products, especially those made of plastic, can leach chemicals. Use natural latex rubber nipples and pacifiers. Teethers and rattles made from untreated wood are fine. Silicone is okay, but the research on this is not extensive. Avoid plastics.
Skin: Now that you have the hang of the risk formula, here’s a question: Which would you consider a greater priority for clean ingredients – shampoo or body lotion? Body lotion it is! Use body lotions with clean ingredients. Body lotion often stays on the skin until the next bath, while shampoo is rinsed within seconds. Besides the obvious products like shampoos, lotions, oils, soaps, and powders, many other chemicals and compounds can enter through the skin. Some residues from laundry soaps, clothing or sheets can enter the body. The bare skin rubbing up against a car seat laden with flame retardants and stain-proof chemicals (PFASs) can absorb these toxic chemicals. Even some VOCs in the air can enter through the skin.
We don’t have definitive answers about how these exposures may affect future health. But we do know that cancer rates and noncommunicable diseases in children are rising and that the environment has a role in this. So we do the best we can to lower the risk by choosing safer products while considering contact time.
Which Baby Products Should Be Prioritized for Safety and Non-Toxicity?
When deciding on specific products to invest more money in, think about a day in the life of your baby, and where principal exposures may occur. Consider these areas:
Safe Sleeping: If you have limited funds, the mattress is the most important product to consider buying organic if you can. Cribs should be solid wood as pressed wood can emit formaldehyde (a carcinogen) for up to two years. This website gives a ton of detail about how to select the most chemically safe crib. Avoid flame retardants and stain/water proofing. Organic bedding, mattress covers, pillows, and sleepwear can be found at very reasonable prices even at places like Target. Always wash in hot water before using.
In the Mouths of Babes: Consider your baby’s pacifiers, rattles, teething items, toys (almost all go in the mouth), bottle nipples and sippy cups. Once your baby starts eating, make every effort to buy or make organic baby food. Foods should be purchased and/or stored in glass. Never microwave foods in plastic. Glass bottles are preferred. Say no to plastics and non-stick cookware.
Save the Skin: Prioritize lotions, oils, powders, laundry soaps, and diapers when looking for clean ingredients. Also consider shampoos, soaps, and sunscreens. The more organic ingredients and fewer number of products and ingredients overall, the better.
Travel and Play Safe: Car seats, strollers, infant carriers, bouncy swings, and activity items are often doused with flame retardants and/or stain repellants that are best avoided if possible.
Breathe Free: Keeping your air clean can be a challenge. Open windows for a good air exchange. Take your shoes off when entering the home. Do not use fragrances. Even natural fragrances can be irritating to undeveloped lungs. Use a vent whenever you cook. Do not clean your oven with the self-cleaning mode; use natural cleaners like baking soda paste. (Yes, it does work.) Reduce VOCs from pressed wood, furniture with polyurethane and formaldehyde, vinyl shower curtains, carpeting, PVC toys, dry-cleaning, cleaners, vinyl flooring, paints, and coatings. Now is not the time to do big painting projects and home remodeling. Vacuum with good HEPA filters or a central vac. Dust frequently; use a microfiber cloth.
Read Next | Taking Care of Newborns during Cold, Flu and COVID-19 Season
Helpful Resources
While quality baby products can be expensive, it is possible to prepare your nursery with excellent, safe products at reasonable cost. The secondhand market is alive and well. Lightly used big ticket items can be found online, use eBay or Facebook. Or think vintage –which is a great way to reuse and recycle –but remember to keep government safety standards in mind, especially when it comes to cribs. Above all, more is not better. Fewer, quality items are better than a lot of—well, you know.
Reliable resources can help you through this process. While you could just google “top organic baby mattresses”, I prefer not to rely on blogs that list items they profit from via the click-throughs (yes, this is a thing). To me, that’s a conflict of interest. In general, I prefer to buy products from companies that have health “baked into” their mission. For example, Naturepedic makes only organic/nontoxic mattresses, including crib mattresses, though they are expensive.
While you are searching for healthy products, you might notice that many have certifications. Some of these are better than others. The best certifications to look for are USDA Certified Organic, GOTS for textiles, and GOLS for latex. I consider Oeko-Tex to be good but note that it Is not certified organic–just guaranteed free from hazardous substances. Forget GreenGuard Gold and CertiPUR-US. These have weak standards that still allow a certain amount of VOCs, toluene, benzene and formaldehyde (these last two are known carcinogens) in the products they certify. Avoid products with the precautionary California Prop 65 warning label which alerts you to the presence of chemicals of concern in the product. If you must paint, look for paints labeled “No-VOCs”. Low-VOC paints still off-gas too many chemicals into the air.
It’s common to feel overwhelmed by this subject. But with the knowledge you’ve gained and the resources available, you can now begin thinking about creating your healthy, non-toxic nursery.
Non-Toxic Baby Product Sites
Here are some non-toxic baby product sites you can consider using:
- Healthy Babies, Bright Future is a terrific and thorough resource for vetting products. They often suggest companies but do not link to them. The site goes beyond infant care and is a great learning tool as well.
- From the Children’s Environmental Health Network see this page about products generally and their Shopping Guide (though note that this data is from 2016 so you may need to call the company to get updated information).
- The Environmental Working Group is another great resource. They have three large and powerful databases: one that enables you to check the safety of personal care products, another for vetting cleaning products, and yet another where you can find out what is in your tap water (which you may decide to filter).
- Women’s Voices for the Earth, a non-profit, has a great list tips to help create a non-toxic environment for your baby. They also have a helpful reference list of chemicals to avoid that are commonly found in baby products.
- Safer Chemicals, Healthy Families is a great place to go to find lists of healthy baby products that have been compiled from other non-profits.
- Madesafe.org also has a good list of chemicals to avoid, as well as a purchasing guide for safe baby products, though note that the companies paid Made Safe for their safety evaluations.
Read Next | This Is Where to Hire an Amazing NYC Nanny
Deborah deMoulpied is a Green Living expert. She created the Environment module of the Anticancer Lifestyle Program, a free, evidence-based online course in lifestyle change for cancer survivors and those interested in the prevention of chronic illness. Deborah has a Master’s degree in Education and was the founder of an environmental green goods store in New Hampshire.
Like what you read? JOIN the Mommybites community to get the latest on FREE online classes, parenting advice, events, childcare listings, casting calls & raffles, and our Parents With Nannies Facebook group. SIGN UP NOW!